Best First Efforts...?


Forum devoted to track & field items of an historical nature.

Best First Efforts...?

Postby jhc68 » Sat Sep 13, 2003 6:51 pm

On another thread a media source was cited purporting that a famous actor/singer (Michael Crawford) ran a 4:23 mile after three weeks training in preparation for a film role. I dismiss the claim as patently absurd and impossible.
But it got me to wondering what IS possible on first efforts and what notable first efforts folks might have seen. For example, years ago when I was coaching cross country, a 10th grader showed up saying he was bored with the marching band and he thought he could run distances because he had his friend time him run a mile. I was sucker enough to ask him all about it and he told me he had run 4:42 all by himself in his first ever mile in tennis shoes on the lumpy old dirt track at our high school. I knew the kid well enough to think he wasn't lying, so I assumed his friend had mistimed or maybe he had only run three laps by mistake. But he eventually made me a believer... by the time he graduated he won the California State Meet 1600m in 4:08 and ran a 14:38 5k on on the track.
So, anyone else have similar stories about extraordinary first efforts on the track or in the field?
jhc68
 
Posts: 3290
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:31 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby Guest » Sat Sep 13, 2003 7:00 pm

Hey Joe--who was the runner? I'm curious.
Guest
 

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby Guest » Tue Sep 16, 2003 10:08 am

Statistically, best "first efforts" are marathon debuts. But I hope some stat freaks out there can come up with 'best debuts' at other events - might be interesting. (What's more interesting than someone 'coming outta nowhere' with a mega-performance?) (though, sadly, such is met with cynicism these days. If it happens at all..)
Guest
 

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby 6 5.5hjsteve » Tue Sep 16, 2003 10:37 am

"first efforts" just do not fit in our sport, so this thread is not of any real use.
6 5.5hjsteve
 
Posts: 436
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:32 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby jhc68 » Tue Sep 16, 2003 1:48 pm

I disagree on both your points, Steve. Extraordinary debuts seem intrinsically interesting to me... what's not to like about someone coming out of no where to post an impressive performance? As for the usefulness of the posts? Which posts on this message board are the really important ones that serve some urgent public need? We are all just a bunch of track nerds wasting time staring at little computer screens and throwing stats and bs opinions around :-) Really, you can find links out of here to websites with world records for running events by lane number. Interesting, yeah, for doofuses like us... useful or important? If you think so you have been spending way too much time here !
jhc68
 
Posts: 3290
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:31 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby RussJD » Wed Sep 17, 2003 4:39 am

How about Edwin Moses running 50.2 in his first 400H? I actually remember seeing that time in Track Newsletter and thinking "Wow, who is that?"
RussJD
 
Posts: 30
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:32 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby dj » Wed Sep 17, 2003 6:19 am

Moses, 50.2? The problem with defining a "first effort." The race you're talking about was in 1976. In '75, Moses had a season's best of 52.0 for the 440H.
dj
 
Posts: 6199
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:31 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby 6 5.5hjsteve » Wed Sep 17, 2003 8:32 am

jhc68, ease up, no offense intended. I think I was perhaps incorrectly interpreting "first efforts" to be a true novice competing for the very first time, such as a large strong NFL football player who has never thrown the shot put, practicing for a week then showing up at a meet, or a very fleet soccer player that never ran in high school showing up at a college track meet. These things do not happen very much. That's all I meant.

A quick story from my Alma Mater that has been told before:

Dave Sime went to Duke on a baseball scholarship. He never ran track in high school.

He wandered down to the track one day in 1955 while a freshman on the baseball team, told coach Bob Chambers " I think I can run some." He then is reputed to have run 100 yards in a sweatsuit, with Chambers timing him, by his account, in "under 10 seconds."

A great story, must have some degree of truth, and then of course, the rest is history....
6 5.5hjsteve
 
Posts: 436
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:32 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby dj » Wed Sep 17, 2003 8:39 am

Another Dave Sime story. Sime was given a tryout by the Philadelphia Phillies. The scouting report indicated he had a decent glove, could hit but not for power (not good for a first baseman), as well as "can't run."
dj
 
Posts: 6199
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:31 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby 6 5.5hjsteve » Wed Sep 17, 2003 8:54 am

sorry to beat my Sime story to death, but the part of the story I left out was that it was supposedly a soft muddy track and he was wearing flats.

Saw Dave up close three years ago at a Duke party at the 2000 NCAA meet held at Duke.. Looked like he could still do it... a very healthy age 64.
6 5.5hjsteve
 
Posts: 436
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:32 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby Guest » Wed Sep 17, 2003 11:13 am

Bforsyth wrote, "Statistically, best "first efforts" are marathon debuts."
-----
Emil Zatopek's Olympic record victory in the marathon at Helsinki on 27 July 1952 comes to mind. He was reported as telling his fellow runners during the race that he was unsure of the pace because he had not previously run a marathon.

In the 1952 Games, Zatopek had already set Olympic records for the 5000m on July 24 and the 10km on July 20. Triple Olympic victories, with Olympic records in each, in eight days!
Guest
 

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby jhc68 » Wed Sep 17, 2003 11:40 am

No worries, Steve, no offense to you, either. We are all doofuses here and, especially, old hi-jumpers need to stick together. Sime stories are great. Seems like he was one of the most overlooked and unlucky athletes in our sport. From the sounds of it, though, he has done very well in the rest of his life.
jhc68
 
Posts: 3290
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:31 am

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby 6 5.5hjsteve » Wed Sep 17, 2003 11:57 am

He is a very successful Ophthamologist in Miami, lives on Key Biscane, has a daughter that was an outstanding collegiate soccer player who is now married to Broncos WR Ed McCaffrey. I do not know him personally, he graduated 7 years ahead of me. But he was still around town in the early 60's after graduating from Duke Medical School doing his internship. Every now and then he would drop by the track, not to run but just to kick a football around. And he sure could punt !
6 5.5hjsteve
 
Posts: 436
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:32 am

Best First Efforts...? Jim Brwon

Postby Guest » Sat Sep 20, 2003 4:13 pm

I recall Jimmy Brown posting an impressive score in his first decathlon. I have long thought that, had he solely focused on the decathlon, he would have been a very good sprinter (in Browns' camps he ran dead heats w/ former Illini hurdler Bobby Mitchell),talented long jumper, a very good weight man, and maybe a superior scorer to Milt Campbell and Rafer Johnson (Jim was faster and stronger than both men)

Bijan
Guest
 

Jim Brown? What if Decathlete?

Postby Guest » Sat Sep 20, 2003 4:19 pm

In all, he won 13 varsity letters at Manhasset. He averaged 14.9 yard per carry as a running back in leading the Indians to their first undefeated season in 29 years, and averaged 38 points per game in basketball. Almost as a lark, at the suggestion of friend and advisor Ken Molloy, he entered the 1956 national decathlon championship in Atlantic City.

With a limited amount of practice using a discus and a heavier shot put borrowed from the Merchant Marine Academy, wearing a pair of track shoes donated by Hofstra coach Howdy Myers after his own had been stolen, competing in a few events for the first time, the high school graduate finished 10th. In a subsequent trip while in college, he earned All-American status by claiming fifth place.
Guest
 

Jim Brown? What if Decathlete?

Postby Guest » Sat Sep 20, 2003 4:26 pm

For those of you who might say "who in heck was Bobby Mitchell?" (the man with whom Jim Brown generally raced even in training camp dashes):

Bobby Mitchell, Hot Springs, Ark.
Set U.S. best in indoor 70-yard hurdles at Illinois in 1958; led NFL in receiving yards in '62 and '63.
Guest
 

Re: Jim Brown? What if Decathlete?

Postby dj » Mon Sep 22, 2003 9:04 am

Let's not do for Jim Brown what we've managed to do for Wilt Chamberlain, Johnny Mathis, et al.

Brown's first appearance in the AAU decathlon was, indeed, in Atlantic City. But that was in 1954, and it was following his freshman year at Syracuse. Brown did finish 10th (5029). The next year, 1955, Brown finished 5th in Crawfordsville, In. (5563).

As for the favorable comparison to Rafer Johnson, that's a stretch. In 1954, Johnson was a high school senior and finished 3rd (5874). But he was beaten by another high schooler, Aubrey Lewis, who was 2nd (6118). (Bob Richards won, 6501.)

Here are the marks for Lewis, Johnson and Brown:
AL \ RJ \JB
11.0 \ 11.1 \ 11.4
21-1 \ 20-7 \ 19-8 3/4
39-7 \ 39-7 1/2 \ 39-7 1/2 (yes, these are correct!)
5-5 1/4 \ 5-9 3/4 \ 5-9 3/4
49.1 \ 51.5 \ 56.3
15.9 \ 15.5 \ 18.4
152-4 \ 122-7 1/2 \ 132-8
9-0 \ 11-4 \ 10-0
164-9 \ 163-9 1/2 \ 154-11
5:00.6 \ 5:29.6 \ 5:01.6

Brown spent the spring (probably) playing freshman lacrosse and spring football rather than running track. Oddly, the events I would have expected him to be best trained for from lacrosse and football - the 100, 400 and LJ - left him behind both high school kids.

There's nothing here to suggest that Brown was faster than Johnson in the sprint-type events, even if one discounts the hurdles as a technical event. And if he's not faster than Johnson, he's certainly not faster than Campbell.

Brown stronger than Johnson and Campbell? Yes, it looks like you can make a good case for that.

By the way, two other finishers (relating to other threads): 5, Joel Shankle (a Duke teammate of Dave Sime in '55); 11, Stan Huntsman (Tennessee coach in '70s and '80s), as well as 4, Jim Podoley (later a running back for da Bears.)
dj
 
Posts: 6199
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:31 am

Re: Jim Brown? What if Decathlete?

Postby Guest » Tue Sep 23, 2003 6:43 pm

You cannot compare the time aspiring Olympians Johnson, Lewis and Campbell devoted to the decathlon than that of Brown. And the '54 event was his very first, no h.s. background like the others (or Bobby Mathias before him).

I bet if C.K. Yang was giving Johnson all he wanted in 1960, a Jim Brown who was strictly a track man from '57 to '60 (or '54-'60)would have been a Daley Thompson-type competitor. His lack of NFL injuries demonstrated he had the stamina. His times and distances would have improved, and w/ coaching (those guys later had "Ducky" Drake, technique would have made him a better jumper/thrower.

Bijan
Guest
 

Re: Jim Brown? What if Decathlete?

Postby dj » Wed Sep 24, 2003 8:06 am

I can't compare them? I thought I did, at least to the extent your earlier comments elicited.

Obviously we're disagreeing about potential. But you said Brown was faster than Johnson and Campbell. I don't think you can back that up. The link to Bobby Mitchell isn't sufficient to make the stretch to beating Campbell or Johnson.

Okay, Johnson was an Olympic aspirant as early as 1954. But the fact is, the 1954 AAU decathlon was the first dec for either of them. (It was the second dec - 1953 AAU being the first - for Lewis.) And let's not discount the fact that Brown is a year older and more developed physically than the two high school guys who beat him.

Great as he was in football, let Brown rest, content with the feeling that he was the best running back ever. He may well have been the best lacrosse player ever, as well. But I certainly won't go so far as to say he would have outscored Rafer Johnson, who may have been the greatest decathlete - or most talented, you pick - ever (see other threads).
dj
 
Posts: 6199
Joined: Sat Oct 08, 2005 4:31 am

Jim Brown? What if Decathlete?

Postby Guest » Wed Sep 24, 2003 8:33 am

Nor did I say he would have beaten him. I said it was a great first effort, and many have wondered what he could have accomplished with complete dedication to the decathlon, with individual event coaching. It's just a speculation like the dream relays on these posts, the match races that never were, the '40 Olympics, et al. Just fun.

Bijan
Guest
 

Re: Best First Efforts...?

Postby Guest » Wed Sep 24, 2003 10:07 am

"Emil Zatopek's Olympic record victory in the marathon at Helsinki on 27 July 1952 comes to mind. He was reported as telling his fellow runners during the race that he was unsure of the pace because he had not previously run a marathon." ......

You left out my favorite part of the story. emil asked one competitor if the pace was quick enough (they were already on record pace), and the other guy though he was kidding and replied (sarcasticaly) "No, its awful slow" and so Emil picked up the pace and left everyone else in the dust.
Guest
 


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests